ALABAMA HERITAGE
  • Magazine
    • Current and Back Issues >
      • Back Issues 141-150 >
        • Issue 147, Winter 2023
        • Issue 146, Fall 2022
        • Issue 145, Summer 2022
        • Issue 144, Spring 2022
        • Issue 143, Winter 2022
        • Issue 142, Fall 2021
        • Issue 141, Summer 2021
      • Back Issues 131-140 >
        • Issue 140, Spring 2021
        • Issue 139, Winter 2021
        • Issue 138, Fall 2020
        • Issue 137, Summer 2020
        • Issue 136, Spring 2020
        • Issue 135, Winter 2020
        • Issue 134, Fall 2019
        • Issue 133, Summer 2019
        • Issue 132 Spring 2019
        • Issue 131, Winter 2019
      • Back Issues 121-130 >
        • Issue 130, Fall 2018
        • Issue 129, Summer 2018
        • Issue 128, Spring 2018
        • Issue 127, Winter 2018
        • Issue 126, Fall 2017
        • Issue 125 Summer 2017
        • Issue 124, Spring 2017
        • Issue 123, Winter 2017
        • Issue 122, Fall 2016
        • Issue 121, Summer 2016
      • Back Issues 111-120 >
        • Issue 120, Spring 2016
        • Issue 119, Winter 2016
        • Issue 118, Fall 2015
        • Issue 117, Summer 2015
        • Issue 116, Spring 2015
        • Issue 115, Winter 2015
        • Issue 114, Fall 2014
        • Issue 113, Summer 2014
        • Issue 112, Spring 2014
        • Issue 111, Winter 2014
      • Back Issues 101-110 >
        • Issue 110, Fall 2013
        • Issue 109, Summer 2013
        • Issue 108, Spring 2013
        • Issue 107, Winter 2013
        • Issue 106, Fall 2012
        • Issue 105, Summer 2012
        • Issue 104, Spring 2012
        • Issue 103, Winter 2012
        • Issue 102, Fall 2011
        • Issue 101, Summer 2011
      • Back Issues 91-100 >
        • Issue 100, Spring 2011
        • Issue 99, Winter 2011
        • Issue 98, Fall 2010
        • Issue 97, Summer 2010
        • Issue 96, Spring 2010
        • Issue 95, Winter 2010
        • Issue 94, Fall 2009
        • Issue 93, Summer 2009
        • Issue 92, Spring 2009
        • Issue 91, Winter 2009
      • Back Issues 81-90 >
        • Issue 90, Fall 2008
        • Issue 89, Summer 2008
        • Issue 88, Spring 2008
        • Issue 87, Winter 2008
        • Issue 86, Fall 2007
        • Issue 85, Summer 2007
        • Issue 84, Spring 2007
        • Issue 83, Winter 2007
        • Issue 82, Fall 2006
        • Issue 81, Summer 2006
      • Back Issues 71-80 >
        • Issue 80, Spring 2006
        • Issue 79, Winter 2006
        • Issue 78, Fall 2005
        • Issue 77, Summer 2005
        • Issue 76, Spring 2005
        • Issue 75, Winter 2005
        • Issue 74, Fall 2004
        • Issue 73, Summer 2004
        • Issue 72, Spring 2004
        • Issue 71, Winter 2004
      • Back Issues 61-70 >
        • Issue 70, Fall 2003
        • Issue 69, Summer 2003
        • Issue 68, Spring 2003
        • Issue 67, Winter 2003
        • Issue 66, Fall 2002
        • Issue 65, Summer 2002
        • Issue 64, Spring 2002
        • Issue 63, Winter 2002
        • Issue 62, Fall 2001
        • Issue 61, Summer 2001
      • Back Issues 51-60 >
        • Issue 60, Spring 2001
        • Issue 59, Winter 2001
        • Issue 58, Fall 2000
        • Issue 57, Summer 2000
        • Issue 56, Spring 2000
        • Issue 55, Winter 2000
        • Issue 54, Fall 1999
        • Issue 53, Summer 1999
        • Issue 52, Spring 1999
        • Issue 51, Winter 1999
      • Back Issues 41-50 >
        • Issue 50, Fall 1998
        • Issue 49, Summer 1998
        • Issue 48, Spring 1998
        • Issue 47, Winter 1998
        • Issue 46, Fall 1997
        • Issue 45, Summer 1997
        • Issue 44, Spring 1997
        • Issue 43, Winter 1997
        • Issue 42, Fall 1996
        • Issue 41, Summer 1996
      • Back Issues 31-40 >
        • Issue 40, Spring 1996
        • Issue 39, Winter 1996
        • Issue 38, Fall 1995
        • Issue 37, Summer 1995
        • Issue 36, Spring 1995
        • Issue 35, Winter 1995
        • Issue 34, Fall 1994
        • Issue 33, Summer 1994
        • Issue 32, Spring 1994
        • Issue 31, Winter 1994
      • Back Issues 21-30 >
        • Issue 30, Fall 1993
        • Issue 29, Summer 1993
        • Issue 28, Spring 1993
        • Issue 27, Winter 1993
        • Issue 26, Fall 1992
        • Issue 25, Summer 1992
        • Issue 24, Spring 1992
        • Issue 23, Winter 1992
        • Issue 22, Fall 1991
        • Issue 21, Summer 1991
      • Back Issues 11-20 >
        • Issue 20, Spring 1991
        • Issue 19, Winter 1991
        • Issue 18, Fall 1990
        • Issue 17, Summer 1990
        • Issue 16, Spring 1990
        • Issue 15, Winter 1990
        • Issue 14, Fall 1989
        • Issue 13, Summer 1989
        • Issue 12, Spring 1989
        • Issue 11, Winter 1989
      • Back Issues 1-10 >
        • Issue 10, Fall 1988
        • Issue 9, Summer 1988
        • Issue 8, Spring 1988
        • Issue 7, Winter 1988
        • Issue 6, Fall 1987
        • Issue 5, Summer 1987
        • Issue 4, Spring 1987
        • Issue 3, Winter 1987
        • Issue 2, Fall 1986
        • Issue 1, Summer 1986
    • Digital Features
    • Links of Interest
    • Bonus Materials >
      • Adventures in Genealogy
      • Alabama Heritage Blog
      • Alabama Territory
      • Becoming Alabama >
        • Creek War Era
        • Civil War Era
        • Civil Rights Movement
      • From the Vault
      • History in Ruins
      • Places in Peril
      • Recipes
  • Online Store
    • Customer Service
  • About Us
    • Awards
    • Meet Our Team
    • News
    • Writer's Guidelines and Submissions
  • Search
  • Donate
Published by The University of Alabama,
The University of Alabama at Birmingham,
and the Alabama Department of Archives and History

Anti-Catholicism in Alabama and Florida in the Early Twentieth Century

7/2/2012

 
Picture
Sidney J. Catts (Library of Congress)
Nothing in Florida above the Nation’s Flag,” announced Sidney J. Catts’s 1916 gubernatorial campaign platform. “As Roman Catholicism puts her allegiance to the pope above the flag,” the statement continued, “Mr. Catts stands against the invasion of the state of Florida in her politics.” Catts hailed from Dallas County, Alabama. He was a Baptist minister in DeFuniak Springs, Florida, before taking up a career in insurance sales. Then, in 1916, despite having no political experience, Catts ran for and won Florida’s governorship, armed with a potent mix of populist appeal and anti-Catholicism.​
​​While anti-Catholicism had become a powerful political tool in the early twentieth century, it had not always been the practice in Florida and Alabama. Prior to this,
there were prominent Catholic politicians. In 1881 voices from Catts’s two home states cheered when west Florida’s Charles W. Jones—a Catholic who emigrated from Ireland at the age of ten—was re-elected to the U.S. Senate. “No
member of the Senate has achieved a wider or more deserved reputation which, we may say, is coexistive with the limits of the Union,” proclaimed a Montgomery, Alabama, newspaper. Jones’s term, however, was nothing short of disastrous. In 1885 he retreated to Detroit where he began showing signs of mental illness, while also hopelessly pursuing a wealthy love interest. One Michigan newspaper dubiously tabbed him, “A Love-Mad Man.” By 1888 Jones lost his senate seat, and soon the ex-senator landed in an insane asylum, where he died in 1897.

​Despite Jones’s inglorious demise, obituaries emerging from Florida and Alabama enshrined his memory, glossed over his final years, and celebrated his political accomplishments and sincere faith. Yet, when Catts arrived, the mere thought of a Catholic politician horrified many non-Catholic voters in this region. Immigration no doubt fueled this ideological change. While most of America’s
new arrivals after the Civil War had settled in northern urban centers, immigrants, many of them Catholic, also filtered southward when Dixie began industrializing. The result was a nativist backlash both in the South and throughout the nation, as those with generational roots in America worried that the newcomers would fundamentally overhaul America’s character and usher in “Roman rule.” Nurturing the paranoia, Missouri’s Wilbur Phelps began publishing The Menace, an anti-Catholic periodical that attracted 1.5 million subscribers by the 1910s. In Atlanta, Tom Watson’s Jeffersonian Magazine joined the fray, printing headlines like, “Th e Roman Catholic Hierarchy: The Deadliest Menace to Our Liberties and Our Civilization,” and “How the Confessional Is Used by Priests to Ruin Women.”

​Birmingham was exceptional in both attracting Catholic immigrants and generating nativist hostility. In 1908 Birmingham had only 38,000 residents. In two years, with the rise of iron and steel mills, greater Birmingham grew to 132,000. Th at number swelled to two hundred thousand a mere decade later. By 1920 the “Pittsburgh of the South” had the highest Catholic population in Alabama, boasting twelve Catholic churches. Not coincidently, the city also had a strong Klan presence, along with a secret fraternal group known as the True Americans.
In 1916 Birmingham’s anti-Catholic contingent was delighted when Catts, fresh from his victory in Florida, arrived in the city to give an address. “The Catholics were about to take Florida,” he proclaimed, “and I told the people
about it wherever I went.” The True Americans publicized the speech, using it to advance their agenda. Meanwhile, one lonely voice of dissent channeled the fears and frustrations of the city’s Catholics. Writing to a local newspaper, Fr. James E. Coyle, a native of Ireland and the priest of
Birmingham’s Saint Paul’s Church, acerbically condemned Catts’s rhetoric to “the malodorous gutter press of Georgia and Missouri.”
Letters soon appeared in Birmingham’s newspapers condemning Coyle. But by
this point, the priest was accustomed to public debate, as well as censure from his bishop. In 1915 Coyle penned a Saint Patrick’s Day poem that expressed his
staunch support for Irish independence, as well as his wish for England’s defeat in the Great War. Critics responded to the priest, labeling him un-American and
un-Christian. In Mobile, Bishop Edward E. Allen caught wind of the dustup and
wrote to Coyle, asking that he “bring the discussion to a speedy close” and heed the instructions of Pope Benedict XV “to remain neutral and let the voice of Faith, Hope and Charity alone be heard about the clang of arms.”

In matters such as these, Bishop Allen tended to be pragmatic, preferring to keep the peace instead of ruffling feathers. But when tragedy struck Birmingham’s Catholic community, Allen set aside his neutrality. On August 11, 1921, a heated confrontation between Edwin R. Stephenson, a Methodist minister, and Father Coyle ensued on the rectory porch of Saint Paul’s. The point of dispute was Stephenson’s eighteen-year-old daughter, Ruth, who Coyle had just wed to Pedro Gussman, a forty-three-year-old Catholic and Puerto Rican immigrant. As the shouts grew louder, Stephenson drew a pistol, fired, and
mortally wounded the forty-eight-year-old priest. At Coyle’s funeral, Bishop Allen spoke with furor and forthrightness, blaming the toxic atmosphere in Birmingham on “disreputable politicians and secret societies,” who had betrayed “American principles of charity, justice and equality for all.”

​As Stephenson’s case headed to trial, reporters from near and far flooded the city. The trial gained national attention, and one northern reporter labeled Birmingham “the American hot bed of anti-Catholic fanaticism.” One of
Stephenson’s attorneys was Hugo L. Black, a 1937 appointee ​to the U.S. Supreme Court. While the evidence against Stephenson was overwhelming, the all-Protestant jury (with a Klansman as the foreman) ruled him not guilty. The judge resolved that “no one can properly criticize the honest verdict of twelve honest men.”

The judge’s prediction was wrong. In public statements, Emmet O’Neal, the former governor of Alabama and a Presbyterian, railed against the verdict, which he said, “made an open season in Alabama for the killing of Catholics.” Many
other non-Catholics in the state would share his outrage. By 1941 Helen McGough, a parishioner of Coyle’s, remembered the priest’s death marking the final chapter of anti-Catholicism in Alabama. “After the trial,” she elaborated, “there followed such revulsion of feeling among the right-minded who before had been bogged down in blindness and indifference that slowly and almost unnoticeably the Ku Klux Klan and their ilk began to lose favor among the people.”

​Indeed, Alabama and Florida have come a long way since the days of Sidney Catts and the True Americans, with Catholics now a mainstay in public life and politics. And in Birmingham, organizers of the Father James E. Coyle Memorial Project have committed to keeping the priest’s memory alive by hosting public talks and maintaining a website with pictures, personal writings, and stories about the priest. Birmingham’s Jim Pinto directs the project, hopeful, as he writes on the website’s welcome page, “that the sharing of the life and death of this holy man may promote greater understanding, reconciliation and peace
among all of God’s children.”

This feature was previously published in Issue 105, Summer 2012.

About the Author
Arthur Remillard is assistant professor of religious studies at Saint Francis University (Loretto, PA). He is the author of Southern Civil Religions: Imagining the Good Society in the Post–Reconstruction Era(University of Georgia Press, 2011) and the book review editor for the Journal of Southern Religion. Joshua D. Rothman, standing editor of the “Southern Religion” department of Alabama Heritage, is associate professor of history at the University of Alabama and director of the university’s Frances S. Summersell Center for the Study of the South, which sponsors this department.
Subscribe to Alabama Heritage

Comments are closed.

    From the Vault

    Read complete classic articles and departments featured in Alabama Heritage magazine in the past 35 years of publishing. You'll find in-depth features along with quirky and fun departments that cover the people, places, and events that make our state great!

    Read More From the Vault

    Archives

    February 2023
    January 2023
    August 2022
    June 2022
    February 2022
    June 2021
    May 2021
    July 2020
    March 2020
    February 2020
    January 2020
    December 2019
    November 2019
    October 2019
    September 2019
    August 2019
    July 2019
    June 2019
    May 2019
    April 2019
    March 2019
    February 2019
    January 2019
    December 2018
    November 2018
    October 2018
    September 2018
    August 2018
    July 2018
    June 2018
    May 2018
    April 2018
    March 2018
    February 2018
    January 2018
    December 2017
    November 2017
    October 2017
    September 2017
    August 2017
    July 2017
    June 2017
    May 2017
    February 2017
    January 2017
    December 2016
    November 2016
    October 2016
    September 2016
    August 2016
    April 2015
    July 2014
    April 2014
    October 2013
    October 2012
    July 2012
    October 2009

    Categories

    All
    African Americans
    Agriculture
    Alabama
    Archeaology
    Architecture
    Avondale
    Avondale Zoo
    Birmingham
    Business
    Cathedral Caverns
    Civil War
    Constitution
    Cuba
    Episcopal Church
    Food
    Guntersville
    Hollywood
    Hunting
    Murder
    Mystery
    National Guard
    Native American
    Nursing
    Photography
    Poarch Creek Indians
    Politics
    Preservation
    Quilts
    Religion
    Revolutionary War
    Sand Mountain
    Whiskey
    Women
    WWI
    WWII

    RSS Feed

Online Store
​Customer Service
Meet Our Team
Board of Directors
Corporate Sponsors
News
Join Our Email List

Employment
UA Disclaimer
UA Privacy Policy ​
​Website comments or questions?  

Email ah.online@ua.edu
Published by The University of Alabama, The University of Alabama at Birmingham, and the Alabama Department of Archives and History
​Alabama Heritage
Box 870342
Tuscaloosa, AL 35487
Local: (205) 348-7467
Toll-Free: (877) 925-2323
Fax: (205) 348-7473

alabama.heritage@ua.edu