Issue 96, Spring 2010
On the cover: The Leninger Place, 1936, by Sidney Dickinson. [Greenville County Museum of Art]
Features
Tattered Banners: Alabama’s Civil War Flags
By Robert Bradley
The Civil War era saw a proliferation of flags in Alabama. The Confederacy used several different flag styles through the course of the war, and individual military units represented themselves with unique banners. Records of them can be frustratingly elusive and, when located, prone to error. Tracing flags and their respective histories remains an important task, because they teach us about the customs, motivations, and practices of Alabama on the brink of and during wartime. Robert Bradley, chief curator for the Alabama Department of Archives and History, shares the stories of some notable flags from the ADAH collection and offers a glimpse of the historical events those banners witnessed.
Sidney Dickinson in Alabama: The Changing South on Canvas
By Martha R. Severens
Painter Sidney Dickinson repeatedly travelled to Alabama from his northern home, following his humanitarian family, who worked at the Calhoun Colored School near Montgomery. Dickinson’s time in Alabama proved artistically fruitful, and the many paintings he created while in the state helped cement his reputation as an artist. Martha Severens offers an intricate look at Dickinson and his exquisite Alabama paintings, which have been exhibited in such sites as the National Academy of Design and the Pennsylvania Academy of the Fine Arts. His works present a community in transition, and they offer sensitive depictions of the dying agricultural lifestyle and the complexity of race relations in the early decades of the twentieth century.
Prince Madoc and the Stubborn Persistence of a Legend
By John C. Hall
Sometimes the most entertaining stories of the past are more fabrication than truth. But what happens when these mythical tales become confused with history? John Hall investigates this phenomenon as revealed in the legend of the Welsh prince Madoc, who supposedly sailed to America centuries before Columbus and discovered Alabama. No reliable historical or archaeological evidence has supported Madoc’s presence in Alabama or even his existence, for that matter. But textbooks embellished the fiction, tours pointed out the legendary landing site, and a historical marker made it official. Madoc became “history”—and a cautionary tale.
Bounding Alabama
By Robert D. Temple
Today, we largely accept the state lines as a commonplace thing, something that’s beyond negotiation. At one time, however, the exact limits of Alabama were anything but certain, and they remained hotly contested. Robert Temple charts the history of Alabama’s borders, offering an informative and colorful glimpse of the state’s geographical limits—limits that have at times been mistakenly charted, revised, and even instrumental in determining the amount of water coursing through the state’s waterways. Bounding Alabama, it turns out, was neither simple nor straightforward; rather, it was a formidable task undertaken by a series of people devoting much time and energy—and quite a bit of discussion—to the effort.
Departments
Southern Architecture and Preservation
Extreme Makeover: Fort Toulouse’s Graves House
By Robert Gamble
When industrial development threatened the property known as “the Old Robinson place,” researchers soon discovered the building had a rich history dating back to the 1830s. Thanks to cooperation between General Electric and the Alabama Historical Commission, the house, now known as the Graves House, was moved to Fort Toulouse Park near Wetumpka, where it stands today. Robert Gamble traces the historic journey of this home, which dates from the early years of Alabama’s statehood, and its current role as an educational historic site.
Becoming Alabama
Quarter by Quarter
By Joseph W. Pearson, Megan L. Bever, and Matthew Downs
Joseph Pearson explores the government’s delicate but essential negotiations to build a Federal Road on Creek land to facilitate trade and military troop movements. Megan Bever looks at the walkout of southern delegates to the Democratic National Convention in 1860, when the group declined a platform to defend slavery rights in new U.S. territories. Finally, Matthew Downs examines the aftermath of student protests in Montgomery and the rise of the Student Nonviolent Coordinating Committee (SNCC).
Art in the South
Where Katie Was Born: Adventures in Provenance
By Robert C. Mellown, with James. K. McNutt
Nearly two decades ago, Robert Mellown received a phone call from a woman interested in learning more about two paintings she owned. Bearing only the words “The house where Katie L. Barry was born, Tuscaloosa, Alabama,” the paintings and their creator were otherwise a mystery. After extensive research in city history, building records, and historical documents, Robert Mellown and James McNutt have shed light this artistic mystery, successfully identifying the site and—most probably—the artist. More importantly, the painting restores for us the original image of an important house now completely altered, a magnificent garden long gone, and a moment in time when a girl named Katie Barry was born.
Reading the Southern Past
Creek Indians throughout History
This quarter’s book review column focuses on the Creek Indians and highlights several texts for general readership. Kathryn E. Holland Braund’s Deerskins & Duffels: The Creek Indian Trade with Anglo-America, 1685–1815, second edition (University of Nebraska Press, 2008) offers a valuable introduction to the Creeks in the greater eighteenth century. A New Order of Things: Property, Power, and the Transformation of the Creek Indians, 1733–1816 (Cambridge University Press, 1999) by Claudio Saunt explores the traditions of the Creek community and the revisions to those traditions that arose as a result of modernity and contact with American lifestyles.
A similar project undergirds Okfuskee: A Creek Indian Town in Colonial America (Harvard University Press, 2004) by Joshua Piker, which investigates life in a prominent Creek town. Finally, a more recent text by Saunt, Black, White, and Indian: Race and the Unmaking of an American Family (Oxford University Press, 2005), traces a single Creek family and its struggles up to the present. Taken together, these books reveal a comprehensive, fascinating, and often disturbing picture of Creek life in America.